Laurie Sutter

Celebrating 20 Years of Serving Plymouth – Let’s Kick Off Summer Together!

As the summer sun shines on our beautiful community, Laurie and her team want to express our heartfelt appreciation for the amazing people of Plymouth and the surrounding areas. It’s hard to believe—it’s been 20 years since we opened our doors in 2005!

From our conveniently located office on E. Jefferson Street—and with the help of modern technology—we’re here to make insurance simple and stress-free. Whether you prefer to stop in, call, or connect via video chat, we’re ready to help you find the coverage that fits your life.

With four licensed representatives and over 45 years of combined experience, we’ve been honored to serve you and are proud to have been recognized multiple times as Top Insurance Office and Agent by the Pilot News. That recognition means the world to us because it comes from you—our community.

In addition to home and auto insurance, we offer condo and renters coverage, life insurance, and commercial policies to support small businesses. No matter where you are in life, we’re here to help protect what matters most.

Laurie and her husband, Mark—both Purdue grads—are proud parents of two and love being part of this vibrant community. Laurie stays actively involved in local organizations like Rotary and Tri Kappa, giving back to the town that has given so much to her.

This summer, let us take care of your insurance needs so you can focus on what matters—sunshine, family, and creating new memories. Call us today for a FREE quote on auto, home, renters, business, or life insurance.

Serving Plymouth and our neighboring Indiana communities—Laurie and her team are here for you, this season and beyond.

Serving locally in the state of Indiana, we're here for you in 46563, 46511, 46501, 46536, 46537, 46513, 46572, 46570, 46504, 46534, 46531, and 46532.